How to Handle Screenplay Notes: The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly

Notes are an integral part of the screenwriting process because screenwriting is a collaborative art. While some of us may want to write in a silo, we will eventually need feedback on our scripts. And it can be hard to hear criticism when you've poured your heart onto the page. How do you handle screenplay notes that you disagree with?

Disney writer Ricky Roxburgh ("Tangled: The Series," and other Disney shows) has become accustomed to receiving notes from studio executives on the regular, and he's got some advice to make it a little easier to swallow those critiques. Better yet, he tells you how to implement those notes so that everyone, including you, will be happy with the final product.

"When I get notes from an executive that I don't agree with, I will typically look for the note behind the note," he began. "Notes are suggestions, not orders."

Once you've got your script to a point where it's ready for notes, most pros recommend taking a step back so you can think objectively about your story and how it functions. Of course, this is hard to do, so try to remove yourself – meaning your attachment to the project – so the notes process doesn't become personal. You'll agree with some notes, find others completely wrong, and may even get some ugly, mean notes in the process. But with Ricky's three steps, you'll know how to deal with every kind of note on your screenplay.

1. Find a Happy Medium

"[Executives] are working with you; they're collaborating with you. I'll try to find a happy medium between where I'm trying to go and what they want to do."

As stated above, screenwriting is part of a collaborative art process – the art of making a film or a TV show. It takes many people to make your story come to life. Most of the time, notes are not personal attacks on your work. The note giver is genuinely there to help you make a better product. While you can maintain your unique voice on the script, you want your story to resonate, so think of the rewrite as your chance to improve your story based on the way other readers perceive it.

2. Find the Value in the Note

"It’s valuable to see how [executives] look at it because they’re looking at it through the lens of the studio. If I flat out don’t agree with it, I look for the note behind the note, and I look at the scene, and I say, “Ok. Well, something’s not resonating with this person.”

As Ross Brown described in his guide to implementing notes, you’re the mechanic, screenwriter. If the note-giver comes to you and says that their car is making a weird noise, it’s your job to figure out where that noise is coming from. The note may not be specific, but there’s likely a particular cause for the problem behind it. Diagnose the issue.

And remember, the person giving the note has a unique perspective. They may ask you to change a scene because they know the cost to shoot it will be astronomically high. They may know that actors won’t likely want to say a particular line. Think about where they’re coming from and what they might see that you do not.

3. Don’t Fear the Note

“Notes shouldn’t be feared; they should be thought about. They’re thoughts.”

It is hard to step back from our project and allow someone to unleash their opinions about it, but try to go into the process with a positive mindset rather than fear. If you’re less afraid of what someone might say about your screenplay and more excited about how they’ll improve it, you’ll have a completely different feeling about the notes when you receive them.

Feeling down about some notes on your script? Don’t let this be your final draft. Get on our private beta list to be the first to try SoCreate Screenwriting Software and its revolutionary features. You’ll be implementing those notes in no time with the new industry standard in screenwriting software.

Use notes as a tool in your writer toolkit. The better you learn to accept and implement notes, the more you’ll improve on your next screenplay.

It isn’t personal,

You may also be interested in...

Disney Writer Ricky Roxburgh Has This Advice for Aspiring Screenwriters

How to Create a Screenwriting Schedule That Works For You, with Emmy-Winning Writer Ricky Roxburgh

Is procrastination a screenwriter’s greatest enemy? In order of most to least detrimental, I think procrastination is up there with self-doubt and creative blocks. But the good news is that we have solutions for all these challenges, and your only job is to implement them. Step one: Create a writing schedule that you can stick to. I genuinely believe all writers need one if they’re serious about getting things done and getting better. And you know what? I have an Emmy-winning expert’s opinion to back me up. “If somebody decides today that they want to be a screenwriter, the first thing I would tell them to ...

Why Disney Writer Ricky Roxburgh's Writing Process Might Work For You, Too

The Writing Schedule That Helped Disney Writer Ricky Roxburgh Go Pro

We've interviewed a lot of screenwriters, and there's one thing they all have in common: they're extremely disciplined when it comes to their professional AND personal writing time. Even if a screenwriter is gainfully employed, they often treat their own writing time like a full-time job. If you're struggling with your writing process, take some cues from the pros, such as Disney writer Ricky Roxburgh, who writes "Tangled: The Series" and works on other Disney TV shows regularly. Even I was surprised by his discipline and the amount of extra time he dedicates to his craft. But you know what? This is what it often takes ...

Disney Writer Ricky Roxburgh Shares His Favorite Online Screenwriting Resources

Screenwriters today have more resources for support, education, and exposure than ever before. So, how do we cut through the clutter of content and get to the good stuff? Disney writer Ricky Roxburgh writes “Tangled: The Series” and works on other Disney TV shows regularly. He's named his top 3 online resources for screenwriters, and they're all FREE. Subscribe, listen, and follow them today. “I follow Chris McQuarrie. His Twitter is great. He answers a lot of questions from people.” Christopher McQuarrie is a screenwriter, producer, and director, working often with Tom Cruise on films including “Top Gun ...